Why I Am No Longer Advertising
Last November, I made the decision to advertise this little blog a few places, hoping that I’d gain new readers and wider exposure. Six months was the internal deadline I set for myself when I started, knowing that at that point I’d reevaluate my financial situation, the blog’s statistical data and my ROI. Yeah, I can rock the financial lingo with the best of them.
Well, there I was at the six month mark last week. In the weeks leading up to it, I’d been thinking a lot about whether or not to pull the plug, and I went into a tailspin of self-doubt because that is part of my process. I’m trying to eliminate that step in my way of handling situations, but in the meantime it remains as absolutely necessary as fear and endless agonizing.
During this time, I made a list of reasons to continue advertising, and reasons to stop, because I like nothing more than to prolong the decision-making process.
The reasons to stop were numerous and weighty. First of all, it’s a butt-load of money that frankly I don’t have. I am nowhere near close to wealthy, more like clinging to the bottom rung of the dying middle class. Come on, I drive a thirteen-year-old Honda, and not out of principle; the money is obviously not a-flowing. This has been my Chanel purse for the decade – an unjustifiably expensive purchase not to be repeated. When I decided to do it in the first place, I tried to see it as a business expense, because I treat my writing as a career. Now though, it’s gotten to the point where I’ve reached my limit – the well’s gone dry, my luck at the table is cold, pick your metaphor, as long as it conveys the whole “financial hardship” aspect I’m trying to get across.
Secondly, my content has shifted since I started this blog. I started out advertising on well-known humor sites, most notably The Bloggess, and I attracted readers looking for more of the same. While I wrote solely silly, neurotic humor posts in the beginning, this is simply no longer the case.
Growing and changing is healthy and inevitable when you work hard at something. I did not burst onto the college scene immediately writing well-constructed essays full of genius ideas; it was painfully time-consuming and took a lot of practice to get to that level. The same is true for blogging, and the same has been true for my fictional side-projects – I’ve grown, my writing is changing.
For a while, I found myself putting on unnecessary pressure to be funny, even when it felt forced or was just the cynical mask I sometimes don to hide whatever it is I’m going through. I started to feel like a phony, trapped in a creative prison of my own making. I HAD TO BE FUNNY ALL THE TIME. It was exhausting. So I’d squeeze in a serious post now and then, with a promise to “bring the funny” the next day. How lame is that, making excuses for my work? I felt like a dancing bear.
There were more reasons to stop advertising, but those were the biggies. My list of the pros was much shorter, with only one item on it, and it actually became a con on closer inspection. A good reason to keep advertising is it does bring in new readers – a significant number of new readers.
HOWEVER. I had started letting these numbers control me in ways I did not like. As I began understanding the financial hardship the advertising put on my budget, I would check the numbers and panic. Who’s going to read my blog if I stop advertising? was a frightening plague of a question that kept me awake at nights, as I am prone to histrionics and unhealthy mental behavior. No one will read me and then I’ll be a loser and sink into internet blogging oblivion! Then everyone will hate me and my husband will leave because I’m such a failure! ad nauseam.
This fear became a much larger struggle than it deserved. You know how when you cling to something so tightly it slips away by virtue of the fact that you can’t let it go? You can’t cultivate anything worthwhile in an environment of desperation, and I was behaving like an addict again – I couldn’t let it go.
So I had to let it go.
I believe that art is a spiritual practice. By letting the fear control me, I shut out any opportunity for God’s blessing and inspiration, and it affected my work.
Yes, I believe in God, and yes, I believe in external creative impulse. Call it what you will, my fear shut off the faucet of good ideas and inspired work. So I’m taking a leap of faith, that by confronting my fear, I will make room for bigger and better things that I couldn’t create with my control-freak nature.
I know I made a big deal about this announcement on Friday when it may not be a big deal to anyone but myself, but nevertheless, there are changes afoot here and I’m still scared of the outcome. Thank you all for your support, and more importantly, for being part of this community.
Let’s see where this takes us, shall we?
56 Comments
thekellygarland
I applaud you for that decision. I was trying to make that decision myself…but at the end of the day, you have to do what is RIGHT for YOU. 🙂 Keep on being yourself!!!! No ads…do it for the love & spirit of you!
Natalie the Singingfool
Exactly! Advertising isn’t bad in and of itself, but how I reacted to it was bad news.
Enchanted Seashells, Confessions of a Tugboat Captain's Wife
Thanks a whole lot, damn, you crawled into my mind and said everything I was thinking, except I haven’t actually spent any $$ on advertising, not yet, I feel guilty if I’m not funny enough or witty enough…I really enjoy your blog, so don’t go away!
Enchanted Seashells, Confessions of a Tugboat Captain’s Wife recently posted…Please Help Find Nichole
Natalie the Singingfool
Haha, too funny! Yeah, pressure is ON when you’re paying for results. I guess I don’t handle that sort of pressure very well. And I think you’ve got a unique niche with your blog – your voice is compelling. 🙂
Enchanted Seashells, Confessions of a Tugboat Captain's Wife
Thank you, but I’m still not sure I can put my finger on exactly what my voice is – I’d probably be more compelled to advertise if I was more consistent. Am I Enchanted Seashells? Am I wife of tugboat man? Am I spoiled Princess? Who knows…
Enchanted Seashells, Confessions of a Tugboat Captain’s Wife recently posted…“I didn’t win the Powerball Jackpot”, says Princess Rosebud
Natalie the Singingfool
ALL OF THE ABOVE. 🙂 No, I get how you feel. I have too many irons in the fire, too. Writer, artist, alcoholic, lunatic, depression survivor, comedienne, perpetual student. There’s more, I just can’t think of it all right now.
JestheMess
That must have been a very hard thing to do, and a hard thing to tell everyone too.
I admit – I initially came for the funny, because you are a funny woman. But I stayed because your writing drew me in. I love reading what you post. You are a talented, funny, amazing, smart woman. Keep doing whatever it is you feel to do!
Natalie the Singingfool
It was hard, but somehow the fear seems smaller now that I’ve admitted it. And thank you for being a loyal reader! 🙂
Vincent
I enjoy reading your blog. I have been on the road you speak of too. I was sniveling at a meeting in 1980, a stranger pulled my arm, hard, asked me if I believed in God? I do… He told me to look up at God and tell Him what Christ did on the cross was not good enough for me; concerned, I listened. He told me not to worry about everything out there. The spot I needed to be working on was between my ears. He shared about filling my mind, with the focus of the meaning of the cross, and my life would change, in a great way, and it did. Everything for me is just great… didn’t use to be like that. Remember, you may only be stumbling forward to success. Keep onward… I can tell you are going in the right direction.
Natalie the Singingfool
Thank you! Yes, the hardest thing for me to focus on is the internal. I want to control & manipulate circumstances instead.
zoe
I was always attracted to your blog for the writing. COngratulations on the next step in the journey. Be confident you already have the “be bold” part down pat!
Natalie the Singingfool
Aw, thank you! This was so encouraging. 🙂
Kate Hall
I’ve never advertised and wasn’t sure how beneficial it was. I’m pretty cheap and frugal, so I never really gave it much consideration. I may have found you through The Bloggess. How long ago did you advertise with her? I’ve been reading your blog since last summer, if I recall correctly.
It’s hard to bring the funny every day. Sometimes I find myself just writing and then throwing in a simile to try to make it funnier. Bleh.
Kate Hall recently posted…10 TV Characters from the 80s(ish) I Loved to Hate
Natalie the Singingfool
Yeah, and what’s more, I have a feeling I’d be funnier if I didn’t pressure myself so much.
I didn’t start advertising with her until November, and I’m still up through the end of the month, when my contract expires, so we probably found each other through some other means…
Julie DeNeen
Good for you! That is a big deal…and I think you’ll be surprised where it takes you. 😛
Natalie the Singingfool
Here’s hoping! 🙂
Ellen
If it’s any comfort, I think I found you through Twitter, so that was free, and I like your more serious posts as much as the funny ones.
Ellen recently posted…I Samma Bil
Natalie the Singingfool
Thank you! I think what’s going to be difficult is being able to count on a certain amount of page views a day, which is so stupid. Stop caring about the page views, Natalie!
Samantha Brinn Merel
I think it will take you amazing places, and I can’t wait to read them.
Samantha Brinn Merel recently posted…Grocery Store Book Shelves
Natalie the Singingfool
Thank you, Samantha! 🙂
B
I found you through the bloggess, but I’m staying for the writing. As long as you keep posting a link on Facebook (until my lazy self has time to update the links on my blog) I’ll keep clicking on over. Enjoy your new freedom. You’ve earned it!
Natalie the Singingfool
Thank you! That means a lot to me. I’m glad you ended up here. 🙂
Kate
I think its good that you are drawing a line. I don’t know much about advertising etc but I can’t imagine it reaps too much rewards when I am sure the Bloggess isn’t name dropping you as well. Good for you!
Kate recently posted…Hooked on books, it works for me
Natalie the Singingfool
Thanks! The rewards were outweighed by my issues with it, lol. Oh, and the money.
Tamara Woods
I’ve been thinking about doing some form of advertising on my blog, but right now I’m so very, very poor. I think it’s important to try something out and then assess whether it’s working for you or not. I’m sure you’ve picked up some readers, who will still reader your post even if you’re not a laugh riot 24/7.
Tamara Woods recently posted…Having hobbies: there’s life outside of writing?
Natalie the Singingfool
Yeah, don’t do it if you have to squeeze pennies to do so.
Katia
Your description of the struggle to upkeep “the funny” is so accurate, I never thought about it from a critical point of view until now, but it is so true. I’ve done all of the above – panicked when I had to force the funny out of nowhere, apologized when I didn’t and promised to bring funny back next time. I’m glad you’ve made your decision (totally identify with prolonging the process as much as possible) and I wish you the best of luck. I believe that great writing will get you further than advertising in the right places.
Katia recently posted…On the Fragility of Life and Teeth
Natalie the Singingfool
Thank you! And I agree, great writing is what keeps people coming back. What scared me was the question, “what if my writing isn’t great?” Agh, not fun to face that potential!
that cynking feeling
The good news about this decision is that there is no harm in stopping the advertising. You can always resume it later if you have the means.
that cynking feeling recently posted…Infuse, hydrate-and persevere
Natalie the Singingfool
Exactly! Although I reeeallly missed the money…;)
Roshni
That’s so wonderfully and honestly expressed! I would love to read more such posts, rather than just funny ones (though please do write funny stuff when you are in the mood!)
Roshni recently posted…What I learned while migrating my blog from Blogger to a self-hosted WordPress blog
Natalie the Singingfool
Thank you!
Mod Mom Beyond IndieDom
That’s why I ended up doing different things on my blog; it’s hard to be funny all the time and there are days when you’re just not gonna feel it. And there’s more I want to say. I want to do poetry and talk about depression. I worry sometimes that I’m too all over the place, but I guess that’s just my personality. My band does that musically too. All over the place. I personally appreciate variety. I applaud your decision. You’re an excellent writer and I think your blog will only grow and grow.
Mod Mom Beyond IndieDom recently posted…The I Don’t Like Mondays Blog Hop
Natalie the Singingfool
Yes, exactly – it’s just my personality. Thanks for your support!
S.J. Faerlind
Well if it helps, I found you on Twitter too. I like your “voice” and your honesty. That’s what keeps me coming back to read your blog. 🙂
Natalie the Singingfool
🙂 Thank you! It means so much.
Chris Plumb
I found you without an ad. Others will as well. Good things can rely more on word of mouth advertising than heavy ad campaigns.
Chris Plumb recently posted…First Car Memories: Good Times and Getting Arrested
Natalie the Singingfool
Here’s hoping…
Karen
I found you through Yeah Write, and I really enjoy reading your blog (the humor as well as the serious stuff) Enjoy your ad free creative life!
Write on.
Natalie the Singingfool
Thank you, Karen! I love Yeah Write. 🙂
Ericamos
You’ll be fine without an ad. I seek out your blog to read it; I don’t even need a notification. The people following you now will continue to follow you, and just immersing yourself in the blogging community will help get your name out there. I think you made the best choice.
Ericamos recently posted…Cold Showers
Natalie the Singingfool
Intellectually I know this, and it’s one of the reasons I chose to stop. That terribly insecure part of my brain still insists on being scared, despite knowing the truth. 😉
Jen
Let me tell you, I totally know where you are coming from. I recently changed my URL and name of my blog because I no longer fit my old one. Dude, that stress was way more than I ever thought it would be. I went through all of the doubt you did about not having any readers, sinking into oblivion. But instead I got a lot of support, support I was not expecting from people who actually *liked* me! Who knew? I applaud your decision, I think you made the right one, it’s no good if you are writing for someone else, and what’s the use if you are driving people to your blog only to have them find something they were not looking for. Keep doing Yeah Write, and awesome hops like this one, you will have readers. Readers who like what the real you wants to write!
Jen recently posted…Twisted MixTape Tuesday 8
Natalie the Singingfool
Thank you so much! Isn’t it funny, that doing something we know is for the best can still be so scary? Thank God most people are more supportive than we give them credit for…;)
Terrye
Advertising – that’s where you put up notices on telephone poles begging to have ppl read your blog, right?
Terrye recently posted…Father’s Day Surprise And Giveaway
Natalie the Singingfool
Haha, yeah – along with standing on a street corner with a megaphone. 😉
Cheryl Nicholl
I read once (i don’t remember what) who reasoned that EVERY decision we make is out of either love or fear, and that every damn choice made out of love of self- others- ice cream) is the correct one. Sounds like you’ve developed a sweet tooth- for yourself. Bravo!
Cheryl Nicholl recently posted…Dancing Around Love
Natalie the Singingfool
Yes, self-love…a new concept for me, but I’m starting to get it…:)
Tamara T.
Good for you! I know it is tough to let go of the “possibilities” that advertising seems to represent, but I have a feeling that you will be just fine. I think God has as even great possibilities for you.
Tamara T. recently posted…Sing a new song
Natalie the Singingfool
Thank you! I’m hoping so.
Punky Coletta
“You know how when you cling to something so tightly it slips away by virtue of the fact that you can’t let it go?”
This is so true and you put it beautifully. By letting go we free up energy for new experiences. I have to remind myself of this sooooo much!
PS. I think I found your blog by clicking on a comment you made on another blog, then kept coming back because I loved your voice, and now you are on my blogroll. I don’t think I even noticed your advertisement on The Bloggess until after I had been following you for quite a while. So an awesome community will still come to you without adverting! Because I am awesome. And I am part of your community. Yay!
Punky Coletta recently posted…Going Cold Turkey
Natalie the Singingfool
Aw, thank you! And you ARE awesome; as such, I’m glad you’re here.
Joanne
Good for you for making the decision that’s best for your blog. I found you on bloggess too, and I love what you write about. My blog has evolved in theme and writing style too and it’s only been 6 months. You gotta write what you know, and write because you love it.
I’ve also followed you on twitter. Hoping to get your blog updates through there. Would love it if you returned the follow 🙂
Happy blogging!
Joanne recently posted…Annoying things people do in restaurants
Natalie the Singingfool
Exactly! That’s what it’s all about.
Joe Cardillo
I have no idea how I found you. But I’ve been reading for a while, and enjoying it. Especially the more serious stuff, so keep it up. I will try to lurk less and comment more =)
Natalie the Singingfool
Haha, well I’m glad you’re here. 😉 And thanks.