Broken hearts – most of us have had them.

I, however, am the Queen of Broken Hearts. Not because I’m special or have had my heart broken more than the average person, but because I am dramatic. I can take a little heartbreak and turn it into a rock opera; I have been known to take YEARS to get over a lost love (to be fair, those particular years were times I spent off my antidepressants).

So when my excellent friend Jen Kehl over at My Skewed View announced that her Twisted MixTape blog hop theme for this week would be broken hearts, I had to jump in, even though I don’t often write about music. Specifically, the theme is “you are the biggest jerk ever for breaking my heart” – I HAVE SO MANY SONGS THAT SPECIFICALLY ANSWER TO THIS THEME!

I’m sorry I shouted, but as this is the most enthusiasm I’ve felt in quite a while, I’m just going to be expressive.

So I’ve organized my selections for my mix tape according to the proper stages of break-up grief, starting with soul-crushing sadness, moving through rage and on to cheerful acceptance and a middle finger. Let’s face it, we all hope for the day when we can say, “Meh, I can do better.”

We just hope it comes before you spend three years of your life crying in your car while the C.D. player blasts Boyz-II-Men’s “End of the Road“… for the fifth consecutive time.

Hemorrhage – Fuel

This one…man, I wore out my burned copy of this. We were soul mates. We were fated to love each other forever. Not Romeo and Juliet forever, but Brontë forever. Eternity and shit.

Don’t fall away and leave love bleeding in my hands, in my hands again 

Dramatic enough for you?

Sidebar: Please don’t watch the music video. It’s terrible. Just listen to the song. Please, this once, trust me.

Back to Black – Amy Winehouse

This one is a good one to indulge in as you move from despair to bitterness; not quite at the rage-roadmark, but well en-route. It’s a little nasty, for my more sensitive readers, but what part about heartbreak is neatly tied up with a rick-rack ribbon?

We only said good-bye with words
I died a hundred times
You go back to her
And I go back to black

Violet – Hole

This song came out when I first discovered music (and, incidentally, boys) – and man, did I ever cling to the angry-girl-screaming aspects of this song.

When they get what they want, they never want it again
Go on, take everything, take everything, I want you to.

Naturally, I appreciate the lyrics more now that I’m older and embittered wise in the ways of love, but something in me always knew that Courtney Love was really pissed off about a guy, and I related.


Yeah, Courtney, we know you’re angry, girl.

Sleep to Dream – Fiona Apple

No one knows heartbreak like Fiona Apple. This one is where healthy anger meets well-timed acceptance…with maybe a little “go to hell.”

Don’t you plead me your case
Don’t bother to explain
Don’t even show me your face
‘Cause it’s a crying shame
Just go back to the rock
From under which you came

Irreplaceable – Beyoncé 

Ah, Beyoncé, you empower me. Every time I hear this song, I want to kick every cad I’ve ever dated to the curb with such confidence. You show us all how it should be done, and that’s why we love you.

And keep talking that mess, that’s fine
Could you walk and talk, at the same time?
And it’s my name that’s on that jag
So go move your bags, let me call you a cab

Rather than moving out, Beyoncé kicks her lying, cheating ex out of the house. At this point in the break-up process of grief, there’s no more need to wallow over a broken heart – “replacing you is so easy.”

If only I could handle my emotions with as much badass panache as Beyoncé. I’d also like to be able to produce a multi-platinum album, but one goal at a time, right?


My hero.

– – –

Photo 1 Source, Photo 2 Source

Jen Kehl


Breaking Up with A Drama Queen — 32 Comments

  1. I love the way you’ve arranged the songs in a progression – so clever! And I’m pretty sure Courtney Love is still angry about something. 😉

    Love that Beyoncé song. I sometimes wish I could go back in time and channel her to deal with certain break-ups…
    Suzanne recently posted…Back to SchoolMy Profile

  2. And she hits it out of the park!!!! I don’t know what makes me happier? That this mix is so awesomely done, that you tell such a great story or that I get to hang with Natalie who I’ve missed so much! I know, I’ve missed you! I’m so happy to hear your voice in my head with this amazing post! I hope you come back again!
    JenKehl recently posted…Twisted MixTape 22My Profile

  3. Ah, Fiona, you haunting and frail little thing. She was a true talent, but didn’t learn like Beyonce, that we also like happy songs.

    My list, because I dated a tortured soul in my youth, would’ve included Tonic’s If You Could Only See, and the Verve Pipe’s Freshmen.

    And Cuba Gooding Jr? I don’t miss you.
    Chris plumb recently posted…High School Didn’t Define Me (or Did It?)My Profile

    • I know. You definitely have to be in a specific mood for Fiona Apple.
      Both of your songs are definitely iconic for breaking up in the mid-90’s, especially if you were dealing with a tortured soul. I do have some experience with those…

  4. I LOVE this post! I just recently went through a break up and a few of these songs are on my break up list. I like to add a few man hater songs too to try and give myself a bad ass boost because I, like you, tend to be a bit of a drama queen. Thanks for showing me I am not alone in my dramatic outbursts of love!
    Shae recently posted…Oui Oui- Ladies Agree, Accents Bring Sexy BackMy Profile

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge


Get every new post on this blog delivered to your Inbox.

Join other followers:

%d bloggers like this: